A man is riding a bike on a hill.
Close this search box.
A watercolor illustration of a typewriter with a note on it.

The Fire by John A. Heldt

by Kellyn Roth |
September 23, 2016

Title: The Fire
Author: John A. Heldt
Series: Northwest Passage, #4
Genre: Time Travel Adventure/Romance
Age-Range: 13+ (upper young adult/adult)
Era: 2000s/1910s (Contemporary/Edwardian)
Setting: Northwest America
Publisher: John A. Heldt (self-published)
Source: from author (in exchange for honest review)
Rating: 3/5 stars
Content: 3/5, not recommended for anyone under thirteen. Mild language, only occasionally. Some violence/death/thematic elements, but nothing gory or frightening. (SPOILERS NOW) I expected there to be another out-of-marriage sex scene, but there was more description this time (it was very no-details and fade-to-black in the last two books I read by Mr. Heldt, and although it wasn’t very detailed and it didn’t go too far … still not a fan). I was disappointed. Also, they didn’t get married, although they would have if they could have. There were also several mentions of visits to prostitutes, and one of the main characters would have become a prostitute, but she was rescued before she actually … *awkwardness* (END OF SPOILERS)

The Fire by John A. Heldt


When Kevin Johnson, 22, goes to Wallace, Idaho, days after his college graduation, he expects to find rest and relaxation as his family prepares his deceased grandfather’s house for sale. Then he discovers a hidden diary and a time portal that can take him to 1910, the year of Halley’s comet and the largest wildfire in U.S. history.

Within hours, Kevin finds himself in the era of horse-drawn wagons, straw hats, and ankle-length dresses. Returning to the same time and place, he decides to travel again and again and make the portal his gateway to summer fun. The adventure takes a more serious turn, however, when the luckless-in-love science major falls for pretty English teacher Sarah Thompson and integrates himself in a community headed for tragedy.

Filled with humor, romance, and heartbreak, THE FIRE, the sequel to THE JOURNEY, follows a conflicted soul through a life-changing journey as he makes his mark on a world he was never meant to see.

Buy on Amazon ~ Add on Goodreads

I was disappointed by The Fire. Now, don’t get me wrong! It was a splendid novel … but it just wasn’t quite as good as The Mine and Indiana Belle.
I’m just gonna get my negatives out of the way now:

  • The love triangle. I always, always hate love triangles! They never end happily, and neither did this one. They always make the guy or girl who has two girls or two guys fighting over him/her seem shallow, and this one did, too. It just took Kevin too long to decide, and then too long to share his secret with Sarah.
  • I didn’t like the main character (Kevin Johnson) although he was a pretty nice guy. It seems to me that he was excited about getting two pretty girls doting on him and couldn’t let one or the other drop. It really annoyed me.
  • The ending didn’t make sense to me. SPOILERS!!! Kevin was still grieving Sarah, right? How could he get over her that quickly when he was absolutely miserable about her five minutes before? Just having his other admirer there changed everything? And how could Sadie possibly accept being his second (and obviously not his second best, too)? END OF SPOILERS!!!
  • I felt like the historical research wasn’t quite as good as it has been in Heldt’s previous books. I don’t mean the details about the actual fire, the comet, and Wallace. Those were very well-researched (or at least I think so – I don’t know much about Wallace, I admit). I mean the details about the social life of 1910. For instance, the morals of the people seemed loser in The Fire than in Heldt’s Indiana Belle, which was set fifteen years, a war, and a Roarin’ 20s later. Maybe I’m wrong; it could just be me.
  • I feel like there just wasn’t enough 1910 (and a few too many anachronisms) in this book, but that could just be me.

There! That’s all. Perhaps you think that’s not enough to move it from four stars to three, but I’m just giving my honest opinion.
The characters were very well-developed and realistic; the writing was pretty good. I’ve always really like Heldt’s comparisons. I have to say this because I read a review in which the reviewer commented that she didn’t particularly care for the similes, and they were often stupid or insulting. For instance, “The place was as empty as the head of a homecoming queen.” Maybe insulting, but true. 😉
Overall, this was a decent novel, but if you really want good reading, Indiana Belle would be my personal John A. Heldt recommendation.
~Kellyn Roth

What do you think of my thoughts?

What do you think of my thoughts?

Follow my blog

Want to receive notifications of new posts? Let\'s make this happen!

Join 1,618 other subscribers