A watercolor illustration of a typewriter with a note on it.

Five Fall Favorites – Day 6 (Top 5 from 2025)

by Kellyn Roth |
September 27, 2025

It’s time for Day 6 of Five Fall Favorites (hosted by Once Upon an Ordinary and Read Another Page)!

Now, this is not my final list by any means, but I’ll discuss some of my 2025 favorites thus far! I’ve only read 13 books this year (not counting my rereads, which are many), and most of them were either Voices of the Future anthologies, my own books, or DNFs!

2025 Favorites

The Mapmaker’s Secret by Jennifer Mistmorgan

The Mapmaker's Secret: Sweet wartime romance with a dash of intrigue (On  Victory's Wings Book 2) - Kindle edition by Mistmorgan, Jennifer. Religion  & Spirituality Kindle eBooks @ Amazon.com.

One of a three-book series that I really enjoyed! This is the final one and was probably my favorite. I actually enjoy the trope that most people don’t, which is fake identity in a romance. This one was fun because both the hero and heroine were doing their best, and you really understood both of their motives. Plus I just feel like the heroine was really complex! This is not the first book I’ve read where the heroine was the muse of an abusive artist, though … so that’s interesting.

The Highland Heist by Pepper Basham

The Highland Heist|Paperback

Another Freddie & Grace mystery! Though not my favorite of their stories, this was nonetheless a lot of fun! And I do love seeing a glimpse of Scotland. The mystery was also fun this time – very classical whodunit. So excited for the next novel!

These Long Shadows by Jennifer Mistmorgan

These Long Shadows: A second chance, marriage-of-convenience love story  from the final days of WWII (On Victory's Wings Book 3) - Kindle edition by  Mistmorgan, Jennifer. Religion & Spirituality Kindle eBooks @

This was the first book I read of this trilogy even though it’s the second novel. I really enjoyed it! I love a good marriage of convenience/marriage of honor story, and this was so sweet. I enjoyed the realistic portrayal of trauma recovery.

The Heart of the Family by Elizabeth Goudge

The Heart of the Family (The Eliot Family Trilogy): Goudge, Elizabeth:  9781619700765: Amazon.com: Books

A reread – this one I appreciated more now then I did on the first couple rereads. Generally, the first and second books are my favorite, and the third kind of drags. It’s mostly set over one long summer afternoon, and that’s … wild. And it is kind of draggy! But some of the ideas and concepts presented here are really good.

The Keeper of the Bees by Gene Stratton Porter

The Keeper of the Bees - Biblioguides

Yes, another reread! I told you I’m rereading a lot of books this year. This is one I hadn’t reread in a while, so I’d forgotten some of the central twists. There are a couple weird moments, as is true of any Gene Stratton Porter novel, but I feel like this has some of the more wholesome and interesting thoughts despite that.

My Team

This year, we’re divided into teams! Allow me to share about my team for this year!

Hannah: hereynolds.com

Katja: littleblossomsforjesus.wordpress.com

Sylvie: sylvieohara106.wixsite.com/my-site-2

Olivia: withloveolivia23.wordpress.com/my-blog

Riley: rileygwriterartist.wordpress.com

Rose: rewriteswithafaeriepen.wordpress.com

The Giveaway

There’s a giveaway for Five Fall Favorites this year! Click this link to find out more and enter:

http://www.rafflecopter.com/rafl/display/6113ead966/?

TTFN!

~Kell~

Are you interested in getting to know me & my books better? Join my email list!

What do you think of my thoughts?

One Response

  1. Ooooo, I need to read all of these! I do have an ARC of Pepper Basham’s book, though. (Yay!) And I think I have the first book in Jennifer Mistmorgan’s series…? Anyways, lovely recs. Thank you for participating once more, Kell 🙂

Leave a Reply to Katja H. LabontéCancel reply

Follow my blog

Want to receive notifications of new posts? Let's make this happen!

Join 1,623 other subscribers